Allegedly with Ellison Barber
Hosted weekly by journalist Ellison Barber, this gripping podcast digs into the most captivating and talked about true crime cases.
What critics are saying
Verdicts use the same scale as your list: highly recommended through avoid — plus optional scores and blurbs.
Nobody on Critic, Sir! has logged a verdict for this title yet. The silence is either respectful or suspicious.
Sign in and use Add to My List below to share your own verdict.
Where to Watch(AU)
Streaming data provided by JustWatch via TMDB.
Cast
Seasons
- Ep 1
1.Gabby Petito: New Revelations
29-04-202644 minEmmy-winning journalist Ellison Barber revisits one of the most publicized true-crime cases of the decade. While the tragic story of Gabby Petito's disappearance and death during h...
- Ep 2
2.Penthouse Predators: The Alexander Brothers
06-05-202640 minEllison Barber unpacks the recent high-profile investigation regarding real estate brokers the Alexander brothers.
- Ep 3
3.Sam Bateman: Polygamist Prophet
13-05-202640 minA conversation between Ellison Barber and cult psychology expert Christine Marie from Trust Me: The False Prophet.
- Ep 4
4.Hell on Wheels: The Case of Mackenzie Shirilla
20-05-202637 min - Ep 5
5.Kouri Richins: Murder She Wrote
27-05-202646 min - Ep 6
6.Architect of Evil: The Gilgo Beach Killer
03-06-202638 min - Ep 7
7.Alex Murdaugh: What's Next
10-06-202640 min - Ep 8
8.Shattered Dreams: The Murders of Monique & Spencer Tepe
17-06-202633 min - Ep 9
9.Viral Homicide: The D4VD Investigation
24-06-202638 min - Ep 10
10.Trouble in Paradise: The Hawaii Cliff Push
01-07-202635 min - Ep 11
11.The Cabo Six: What Really Happened to Shanquella Robinson?
08-07-202641 min - Ep 12
12.Escape to Italy: Suspected Wife Killer Lee Gilley Flees Texas
15-07-202642 min - Ep 13
13.Courtney & Christian: Love Kills
22-07-202643 min - Ep 14
14.Bryan Kohberger: Were Red Flags Missed?
29-07-202644 min - Ep 15
15.The Au Pair Affair Murders
05-08-202649 min - Ep 16
16.Bridge Guy: Will the Delphi Conviction be Overturned?
12-08-202643 min - Ep 17
17.Sworn to Protect, Charged with Murder: The Death of Sandra Birchmore
19-08-202641 min - Ep 18
18.Ungodly: The Reckoning of Pastor JP Miller
26-08-202641 min - Ep 19
19.Episode 19
02-09-2026
Watching Lists
to create and edit public lists.
Loading lists…
Purchase & Discovery
Find this title on Amazon
Digital
Prime Video & digitalAmazon mixes rent, buy, and Prime in one place — one search covers the usual options.
Physical edition
4K Blu-ray & physical releasesSearch on AmazonOfficial merchandise
Official-style merch searchApparel, collectibles, and moreAs an Amazon Associate, Critic, Sir! earns from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure