Critic, Sir! logoCritic, Sir!
TV ShowReturning Series

Mystery Brony Theater 4000

2013
3 seasons
16 episodes
AnimationComedy

The series stars Evan Bernardi, Zack Wanamaker as they make a deal with Hasbro to leave their own blind commentary on movies and episodes of My Little Pony from the past, in exchange for writing their OC's into the show. They are then sent to Ponyville where they spend their time in the theater watching a different video. Unfortunately they do not know what they are going to be sent or what to expect, but with the help of their friends, including their friend Cruizer, they can last until they hit them all

Sign in to add to your list

What critics are saying

Verdicts use the same scale as your list: highly recommended through avoid — plus optional scores and blurbs.

Highly recommended Recommend Give it a go Neutral Avoid

Nobody on Critic, Sir! has logged a verdict for this title yet. The silence is either respectful or suspicious.

Sign in and use Add to My List below to share your own verdict.

Cast

Z

Zach Wanamaker

E

Evan Higgins

E

Evan Bernardi

C

Cameron Hall

S

Sydney Plaza

C

Chloe Hatfield

A

Allen Smithee

J

Justin Sprauer

S

Sidney Alous

A

Alyssa Kurzenknabe

Seasons

  • Ep 1

    1.Rescue at Midnight Castle

    19-12-2013

    The crew takes on Rescue at Midnight Castle

  • Ep 2

    2.Fugitive Flowers

    19-12-2013

    The crew takes on Fugitive Flowers

  • Ep 3

    3.Princess Promenade

    19-12-2013

    The crew takes on Princess Promenade

  • Ep 4

    4.Newborn Cuties

    28-02-2014

    The crew takes on Newborn Cuties, but Davin croaks during the riffing

  • Ep 5

    5.Baby It's Cold Outside

    09-02-2015

    With Davin gone, Nana and Finnster, send Higgins., and their assignment, Gen. 1 "Baby It's Cold Outside".

  • Ep 6

    6.Magic Coins (Part 1)

    09-02-2015

    After Evan and Cameron finished playing a round of Lucky Ducks, after Higgins beat him 45 times straight, the guys are sent part 1 of Magic Coins

  • Ep 7

    7.The Runaway Rainbow

    14-10-2016

    While Nana and Finnster are in Rehoboth, Delaware, Final Cut delivers them a Gen 3 movie, thats said to be the worst by the brony community, "The Runaway Rainbow"

Watching Lists

Sign in to create and edit public lists.

Loading lists…

Purchase & Discovery

Find this title on Amazon

Digital

Prime Video & digital

Amazon mixes rent, buy, and Prime in one place — one search covers the usual options.

Physical edition

4K Blu-ray & physical releasesSearch on Amazon

Official merchandise

Official-style merch searchApparel, collectibles, and more

As an Amazon Associate, Critic, Sir! earns from qualifying purchases. Full disclosure