TV ShowReturning Series

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

7.0 / 10

2026

2 seasons

8 episodes

Mystery

After a breakup, Cheryl takes over an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek. Strange stuffed animals, a kidnapping, and hidden feuds force her, Naomi, and Levi into a thrilling search.

What critics are saying

Verdicts use the same scale as your list: highly recommended through avoid — plus optional scores and blurbs.

Highly recommended Recommend Give it a go Neutral Avoid

Nobody on Critic, Sir! has logged a verdict for this title yet. The silence is either respectful or suspicious.

Trailer

Where to Watch(AU)

Philo

UP Faith & Family Apple TV Channel

UP Faith & Family Amazon Channel

Streaming data provided by JustWatch via TMDB.

Cast

Galadriel Stineman

Denise Gossett

Kevin Joy

Lance E. Nichols

Ryan O'Quinn

Riley Beeson

Updates

NEW EPISODE ALERT

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries has an upcoming episode on 2026-05-14.

Seasons

1.The Buggy Before the Horse
23-04-202644m
A hidden intruder tests faith and compassion as Cheryl races to protect Sugarcreek before Thanksgiving.
2.A Season of Secrets
30-04-2026
A vanished Amish boy, secret texts, and buried truths pull Cheryl into Sugarcreek’s most personal mystery.
3.O Little Town of Sugarcreek
07-05-2026
Christmas thefts and a returned ex force Cheryl to protect an innocent friend and her heart.
4.Off the Beaten Path
14-05-2026
A vanished bus, fake FBI agents, and hidden feelings test Cheryl’s courage—and her heart.
5.Simply Vanished
21-05-2026
A hidden chute leads Cheryl to a decades-old disappearance—and a birthday she’ll never forget.
6.Stitch in Time
28-05-2026
A mysterious quilt leads Cheryl to a buried secret—and a family ready to heal.
7.Mason Jar Mayhem
04-06-2026
Hidden wartime treasures spark a mystery Cheryl must solve before history is lost again.
8.When There’s a Will
11-06-2026
A missing deed, county corruption, and a race against time threaten Levi’s land and future.